Side by side
| Public housing | Section 8 voucher | |
|---|---|---|
| Who owns the home | The housing authority | A private landlord |
| Can you choose where to live? | You get offered a unit | Yes, any unit that passes inspection and whose owner accepts the voucher |
| Income limit | Up to 80% of area median | Usually up to 50% of area median |
| Your rent | About 30% of adjusted income, or a flat rent | About 30% of adjusted income, plus any amount above the payment standard |
| Can you move to another city? | You must apply again there | Yes, with portability |
| Waiting list | Separate list, often by property or bedroom size | Separate list, often longer |
When public housing makes sense
If your income is between 50% and 80% of the area median, public housing is usually the only option. Its waiting lists can be shorter than the voucher list in the same agency, especially for some bedroom sizes or senior buildings.
When a voucher makes sense
A voucher gives you choice of neighborhood and school, and you can take it with you if you move. The trade-off is that you need to find a landlord who accepts it within the search period.
Which agencies run each program
Some agencies run only public housing, some only vouchers, and many run both. Every agency page on this site says which programs it has and how many units and vouchers HUD reports. Find yours on your state page.
Frequently asked questions
Can I apply for public housing and Section 8 at the same time?
Yes, and it is a good idea. They have separate waiting lists, even within the same agency.
Which is faster?
It depends on the agency. Ask each one about the wait for your bedroom size; public housing is sometimes faster, especially in senior buildings.
Is the rent the same?
Both are based on 30% of adjusted income. Public housing also offers a flat rent option, and with a voucher you may pay more if you choose a unit above the payment standard.
More Section 8 guides
Official sources: HUD: Public Housing Program · HUD: Housing Choice Voucher Program · 24 CFR Part 960 (admission to public housing) · 24 CFR Part 982 (Section 8 tenant-based assistance). Written and reviewed by Agustin Mendez. How we check the information.